The 43rd General Meeting of ILC Physics Subgroup

Asia/Tokyo
Keisuke Fujii (IPNS, KEK)
Description

Date/Time: 10:30~17:30 JST, September 5, 2015

Place: Room 425, Building No.3, KEK

Official Language: English

Video Conference ID: 603 (KEK MCU2)

Fuze connection: http://fuze.me/30410114

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A Summary of The 43nd General Meeting of the ILC Physics Subgroup
September 5, 2015 (Sat) at Room 425, Building 3, KEK
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
0) Attendants:
Present at KEK:
A.Ishikawa (Tohoku)
K.Fujii    (KEK)
J.Tian     (KEK)
J.Yan      (KEK)
T.Ogawa    (Sokendai)
K.Hidaka   (Tokyo gakugei)
H.Ono      (NDU)

Remote connection:
K.Ikematsu     (Saga)
Y.Sudo         (Kyushu)

0) Opening comments (K.Fujii)

1) Leptonic recoil mass analysis (Jacqulline Yan)
Status:
 Improvements since the last meeting:
    Evis cut
    TMVA
 Cross section measurements (combined with invisible cross section)
   Ecm=250GeV
    (-0.8,+0.3)    2.65%     34.2MeV
    (+0.8,-0.3)    2.95%     39.2MeV
   Ecm=350GeV
    (-0.8,+0.3)    3.27%     92MeV
    (+0.8,-0.3)    3.63%    105MeV
   Ecm=500GeV
    (-0.8,+0.3)    5.29%    500MeV
    (+0.8,-0.3)    5.34%    586MeV
 Investigation of mode dependence
     Major problem turned out to be coming from wrong lepton pairing for H->ZZ*, WW*.
    -> Chi2 method to select the correct pair.
        -> Improved but not sufficiently.
    -> The bias is nevertheless very small already for the SM-like branching ratios,
       negligible even for H20.
Next Step:
- TMVA for selecting best pair.
- increase MC statistics.
- publication.
- systematic error due to beam spectrum.


2) Anomalous HVV couplings (Tomohisa Ogawa)
Status:
 Anomalous HVV couplings:
    SM-like, FF, FFtilde
 Zh production:
   Observables:
    - production angle of Z 
    - delta phi (angle btw production and decay planes of Z)
    - sigma_Zh
 Update since the last meeting:
   Fit phi and theta simultaneously.
   Studied the Ecm dependence.
    -> Sensitivity to anomalous coupling, in particular for costh, seems to
       increase with Ecm dramatically.
   Updated the analysis to separate the sensitivity coming from shape and that
   from the total cross section.
   Optimize the cuts to maximize the overall signal significance, while keeping the 
   (phi and costh) acceptance as flat as possible.
   Updated the analysis to separate the sensitivity coming from shape and that
   from the total cross section. -> new chi2 definition.
    -> New contours. -> delta b ~ 0.01, delta btild ~ 0.01 with 500fb-1 @ 500GeV.
Next Step:
- Do other channels and add them to the chi2.


3) Top Yukawa coupling study at 500 GeV (Yuji Sudo)
Status:
 500GeV (500fb-1), (-0.8,+0.3)
 Updates:
    new 6f samples
    jet pairing by maximum likelihood
    -> 10% improvement for b-pair from the Higgs.
 Results: (significance)
    (-0.8,+0.3)    2.01 (8j) 
            1.91 (l6j)
            0.88 (2l2j)
    (+0.8,-0.3)    1.36 (8j) 
            1.30 (l6j)
            0.61 (2l2j)
    The numbers are for cut-based selection.
Next step:
- Resolve the problem with the cross section estimates.
— optimize the selection.


4) Higgs BR study (Hiroaki Ono)
Status:
 500GeV analysis just started.
 planning to do template smoothing, variable bin widths to improve template stability.
Next Step:
- investigate more on template stability.
- TMVA.
- Summarize 250 analysis.


5) Tools (Junping Tian)
Status:
 Isolated lepton tagging algorithms
   new MVA-based algorithm outperforms the old ones: Cone and LAL significantly.
    -> 0.02% BG efficiency at 90% signal efficiency.
    -> new training sample -> another factor of 2 for muons.
    -> Investigating the source of mis-tagging.
        most dominant was mus from jets.
        2nd dominant was found to be Kaons (K to muv decay in CAL).
        For electrons 2nd dominant was pions (charge exchange in CAL).
 New jet-clustering
   Potential impact on HHH coupling: 
    40% if we have perfect color-singlet clustering.
   We know that Durham is correct till 20 mini-jets.
       idea is to assign at this level the probability using parton shower PDF.
    -> there seems to be correlation between these 20 mini-jets and partons
          to certain extent.
   Strategy is to follow all the history of parton showering.
Next Step:
- construct likelihood for parton showering 


6) Discussions: all
  Our highest priority is to prepare a short summary of BSM prospects at ILC.
  Given the short time scale, we need to rely on existing studies.


----------------------------------------------------------
The slides shown at the meeting is available from
https://agenda.linearcollider.org/event/6793/
see them for details.
---------------------------------------------------------

*) Meeting Schedule:
 Next general meeting (2015/10/24 10:30) : Conf.ID: 667


Working group web page:
http://www-jlc.kek.jp/jlc/en/subg/physics

There are minutes attached to this event. Show them.
    • 10:30 11:00
      Opening Remarks 30m
      Speaker: Keisuke Fujii (IPNS, KEK)
      Slides
    • 11:00 11:20
      recoil mass study using Z-->ll at 250, 350 and 500 GeV ILC 20m
      Speaker: Dr Jacqueline Yan (KEK)
      Slides
    • 11:20 11:40
      study of anomalous HVV coupling measurement at ILC 20m
      Speaker: Tomohisa Ogawa (Shinshu University)
      Slides
    • 11:40 12:00
      Top-Yukawa coupling study at 500 GeV 20m
      Speaker: Yuji SUDO (Kyushu University)
      Slides
    • 12:00 13:30
      Lunch 1h 30m
    • 13:30 13:50
      Branching ratio study of H-->bb/cc/gg 20m
      Speaker: Dr Hiroaki Ono (Nippon Dental University)
      Slides
    • 13:50 14:10
      Isolated lepton tagging and new jet clustering studies 20m
      Speaker: Dr Junping Tian (KEK)
      Slides
    • 14:10 15:10
      Discussion: next plans, missing studies, etc.